Open Thread Update: Online Dating Follies

Last time (column below) I shared my experiences with online dating and asked readers what they thought of it. The results were a surprising mix.

Of the 117 respondents, some 47 percent of respondents said they tried online dating and were unimpressed. (Apparently their experiences were too  traumatic to share any details in the comments, though!)  Another 34 percent said “No’ and they didn’t plan to date online…and 10 percent said they got scammed!

The good news? The remaining nine percent had more balanced and encouraging news.

 “If it’s too good to be true, it probably is. But the best lesson I learned was to value my self and identify what I really wanted in a mate. “

-Mary H.

..she also shared her great news in the rest of her comments, along with several others who met people and are happily dating. Good job!

Two respondents reported special challenges for non-meat eaters in the online dating scene.  Marie W. says “I really think the men thought I was a kook…” but one vegan adapted and found a smart strategy….

‘Because of the way I eat, organic vegan, I do not entertain eating out, on a date. I have become friends with some…”

-C. Hartfield

(Prof) P J Gammarano offers some sage advice for online daters. “Anyone with genuine legit intentions who tries this venue for meeting someone romantically had better tell several loved ones/friends/relatives that they are trying this–so that if something unintended happens those people can help out! Back in the day it was so different!”

You can say that again, Professor.

Reader JL has a wonderful perspective for online and offline daters alike:

 “How else to meet people? I also changed sites and my attitude. I now look at this as a great adventure. Life is about the journey not the destination.”


Lastly a shout out to reader Charles Moore for his nice comment.

“Had to laugh out loud. Entertaining piece. Subject would make for a great SP instruction/discussion series…”

Thanks!  That’s what keeps me going, Charles.

That’s it for now. We’ll keep the comments open so you can continue to comment and vote. Thanks for your thoughts!

Original post below:

“Try online dating!” my brother kept urging me in the years after my husband, Michael died.  It felt weird and very artificial, but I took the plunge. I sent in a picture, wrote a profile and posted.

Many of the replies read like the requirement specs software app designers list to use their software.  Instead of “Must have 3 MBs of space and run Windows 10 or later,” these said, “Must like slingback heels,” or “curvy but not overweight.”  The men were all “fit” and “athletic.” It was offputting to feel like a commodity in Aisle Three.

If it seems too good to be true 

One guy seemed ok – he was cute, but not too cute and sounded interesting.  We met at the Met, and he  was a good conversationalist who liked the same things I liked. He was OK with splitting the check.

During our short walk afterward, I sniffed trouble. He volunteered that Valentine’s Day was coming up and he had a business trip. What business? “Import Export.” “With what?” “All sorts of things.” He gave me his number, but not his neighborhood, just “Queens.”

When your date starts sounding like a Seinfeld episode, it’s time to bail. I said goodnight and left him downstairs. When I got upstairs, I got busy. (Do not mess with a trained reporter.)

Uh oh

I discovered that his number was a pay-as-you-go burner phone, usually purchased because of a bad credit history. Further research revealed that he was known to the court system as a con artist who stiffed credit card companies, local retailers and the nursing home where his mom lived.

I sent him a note that we weren’t a match, and he promptly changed his contact email and photo…possibly to look for a new pigeon.

Says who?

Then there was the guy from Connecticut who thought  the “Third Date Rule” was legally binding and made two clumsy attempts to engineer a sleepover that were straight out of a 50’s movie.  Besides telegraphing his expectations, he couldn’t even fake a cursory interest in me as a human being…like, say, asking a single follow up question to anything I said during our third date. He kept looking at his watch like a man impatient for the delivery of a long-expected package.

I tried a few more times – with the same well-established website – but nothing clicked.  I then tried another online dating service that claimed it was for intellectual types.  The first email I got was a dick pic.

Luckily, I have a big circle of friends and I’m in no hurry. But what about you? What’s your experience been with the Online Dating Follies? take out informal poll and tell us more in the comments!


Virge Randall is Senior Planet’s Managing Editor. She is also a freelance culture reporter who seeks out hidden gems and unsung (or undersung) treasures for Straus Newspapers; her blog “Don’t Get Me Started” puts a quirky new spin on Old School New York City. Send Open Thread suggestions to her at

Middle photo:  Markus Winkler on Unsplash